Top 5 Legal SEO Companies

As you can tell from this BLOG, I am obsessively tracking rankings in hundreds of markets in the three most competitive online practice areas; personal injury, family law and criminal law. I keep a database of over 3000 web agencies and over 200 agencies that focus on the legal market. In addition, during my time at ilawyermarketing, I developed the Average Rank Consistency Score (ARC), which was a way to track ranking consistency on 8 competitive keywords.

Through these efforts I have found that there are 5 agencies that stand out in terms of consistent ranking performance in the most competitive markets. Here are the 5 companies listed alphabetically along with 3 of their showcase clients and their DR, est monthly traffic and est organic traffic value. While every SEO company will have a “showcase” client, the difference with these companies is that most of their clients are getting good or great organic results.

Elite Legal Marketing:
Of the five companies, Elite has the smallest footprint, with just 60 clients nationally and usually a much lower price point. *Full disclosure, In October 2025, I became a partner in Elite Legal Marketing.
The Barnes Firm (PI) – NYC/LA/Oak – 48, 61.9k, $1m
Malman Law (PI) – Chicago, IL 41, 48.7k, $676k
TK Injury Lawyers (PI) – Austin, TX – 38, 9.6k, $189k

Hennessey Digital
They have lost some of their main showcase clients in recent years; Ben Crump and Morris Bart, but they remain one of the top organic SEO performers in the legal space.
John Foy (PI) – Atlanta, GA 58, 187k, $1.6m
Anidjar & Levine (PI) – Fort Lauderdale, FL 51, 276, $353k
Morelli Law (PI) – New York, NY 34, 23.8k, $121k

iLawyermarketing
My former company creates the best designs in the industry and has a stable of showcase SEO clients. They are by far the largest of the 5 companies – and with the purchase of Law Rank the combined company now has well 300+ clients.
Panish Shea (PI) – Los Angeles, CA 46, 61k, $744k
Clifford Law (PI) – Chicago, IL 49, 20.7k, $321k
Elk & Elk (PI) – Cleveland, OH 39, 26.3k, $342k

Law Rank
Last June, Law Rank was purchased by Everservice, the same private equity company that owns iLawyermarketing, so you need to think of ilawyermarketing and Law Rank as one.
Rosenbaum Personal Injury Lawyers (PI) – NYC 43, 76.2k, $1.3m
Attorney Brian White (PI) – Houston, TX 51, 51.7k, $1m
Curiel & Runnion (PI) – Phoenix, AZ 43, 9.5k, $180k

Rankings IO
One of the top SEO companies in the legal space for the past 10 years.
Jennifer Gore (PI) – Atlanta, GA 37, 23.5k, $609k
Wilshire Law Firm (PI) – Los Angeles, CA – 58, 37.3k, $400k
Levin Injury (PI) – Philadelphia, PA 51, 10.7k, $110k